My family and I had a great stay. The "cabin", as my kids called it, is above the garage. Don't let that deter you! It's a lovely, clean, comfortable place with a modern cabin feel. Very clean with no knick knacks (good if you have young kids).
I wondered if not being at ground level would be a pain in terms of getting to the lake, but it wasn't at all. It's quite close, and I actually liked having more control of when my kids were at the water... No 2 year olds escaping to the beech unattended!
The neighbor, caretaker, and check in person, Karal, was very friendly and helpful. She supplied a lighter for the fire when needed. Mike, the owner, was also easy to text with as needed.
Be sure to bring washing machine soap and shampoo, the latter I thought was supplied but wasn't. It was nice to have the ability to clean clothes, even on a short trip.
All in all, the area is quiet on a smallish lake. Very relaxing. The town of Dexter had more stores than I would think for this size town, which was a plus.