I traveled to Fenwick Island with two girlfriends for a moms getaway weekend in late Sept. The weather wasn't very cooperative, so we didn't get to enjoy the beach or water activities, but it was a lovely place to enjoy a cozy weekend with friends.
The townhouse is right on the bay, with beautiful water views from the living room and two of the bedrooms. The kitchen is well stocked, and the decor is nice and inviting. The only slight complaint we have is that the beds in the two main bedrooms aren't very comfortable. Maybe mattress pads would help?
We enjoyed the Mexican restaurant right across the parking lot, which was convenient to walk to. We tried to eat at Catch 54 next door, but they were closed for a private party (oddly, this happened when my husband and I visited Fenwick Island last year, so I would recommend calling a few days in advance to check their schedule.) We'll eat there one day! We also really liked the lobster rolls at the Lobster Shanty down the road, brunch at Harpoon Hannahs, and several restaurants in Bethenny Beach, about 10-15 minutes away.
I would highly recommend this property, and we would love to stay here again one day.