I cannot fault this house/owner/manager for the attention to detail (decor & amenities), location and overall house arrangement (sleeping-beds/linens were great). Kitchen was fully stocked.
However, I would suggest that each time the house is cleaned, I would have them check the smoke alarms &/or carbon monoxide detection devices, or automatically change every 6 months. At around1:00 a.m. first night, we were rudely awakened by deafening fire alarms in the house. Called management. They told us to call police. Called police. They told us to vacate the premises (raining outside). The police contacted the fire dept. for us. They came and inspected premises for CM. Nothing detected. Our fear was that PERHAPs the fireplace was leaking CM, because there definitely was not a fire. Go back to bed. It happened again at 2:30 a.m. No one, not even the fire department, was able to spot the one detector that needed a new battery, because it stayed green until it went off, THEN it turned red.
Assuming that someone had been there the night before (or several nights-New Years Eve), because I don't think they had the time to clean the hot tub. We still used it.
The garage is marketed as a game room, but we found it too cold to enjoy. None of the kids (teens, who can weather most anything) used it. A space heater would be nice (or some form of heat).
I would rent it again.