Our family had a great (but all too brief) stay at the Amish Guest House.
The location is great, right in the heart of Amish country: most of the shops, restaurants, and attractions you might want to visit are within a short drive, and right nearby are great spots like Immergut Pretzels for a great snack, Stolzfus Meats for stuff to cook yourself or bring home, and lots of shops.
The house itself is a cute property that's been nicely updated and is perfect for a small family or 1-2 couples. The availability of a NEMA 14-50 (50A) outlet for charging EVs was a huge bonus, alleviating the need to find places to charge; just make sure to remember to bring your own charger to plug into the outlet. There's a great fire pit for spending evenings outside, or a huge TV if you want to spend them inside. The house is on a fairly busy road, so you will hear road noise inside the house; however, it does quiet down at night, and we never found it to be an issue during our stay (we slept just fine).
Daniel and Catherine were very responsive and easy to work with. We'd definitely enjoy staying again in the future.