We stayed in Kelly's VRBO apartment in Joseph City for three nights. It is split level with the bedrooms and bathroom upstairs and the kitchen, breakfast table, and living room downstairs. The downstairs is mostly below ground so not a lot of windows and the kitchen window looked out on an enclosure with apartments across the way. The rooms are on the smaller side, but certainly comfortable for a small group.
The apartment is located directly across from a nice park with a large grass area and picnic tables. There are trains that pass by, but the noise wasn't disruptive.
The apartment was well stocked with lots of pots and pans, cutlery, teas and coffee, spices, olive oil, paper goods, etc. Similarly, the bathroom was well stocked with shampoo, conditioner, shower gel, and pretty nice towels.
Kelly is a really good host. He responded to our emails quickly, provided food for breakfasts, and left all sorts of books and games. He also did a good job decorating the apartment in a ‘Route 66’ theme.
Being truthful here, if you are looking for an upscale residence, this isn’t it, but it is one of the nicest lodgings you will find in Joseph City. That said, Kelly’s apartment was clean, functional, relatively inexpensive, and located only about a 30 minute drive from the Petrified Forest and Painted Desert which were our main focus, so, all in all, we were pleased with the accommodations.