The location was great. We rented bikes for the week and everything was a short bike ride away - which we preferred. The cottage was okay, perfect size for 2 of us. The other 2 cottages on the property were vacant during our stay, so we had the shared pool to ourselves - which was nice!
Our only complaints were: 1) the floors were not clean - my husband took off his shoes and after 10 minutes of walking around inside the cottage, his feet were noticeably dirty. Not a deal breaker - we just wore flip flops inside. 2) There was an overwhelming musty smell that we noticed immediately when we opened the door. There was a dehumidifier running in the cottage, but everything still felt damp/wet - the towels, the couch, the bedding, and all of our clean clothes that we hung up in the closet. Unfortunately, I had to wash our clothes twice upon returning home to get the odor out of our clothing, and our suitcases are still airing out.
Overall, we enjoyed Key West - how could you not?! We didn't spend a lot of time hanging out in the cottage so the issues I listed above were tolerable as we were there to get out, explore and enjoy all Key West has to offer, which we did!