My wife and I stayed here for a week while I attended a course at MISA. In short, this was the perfect place for us and our dog. First, the house is perfectly located in close proximity to town, MISA and an idyllic beach, all while being situated remotely in the woods, removed from everyone. Secondly, the house was so clean and comfortable. The minute we walked in, we knew we were going to be able to utterly relax. Related - the house is well organized with labels on light switches and thorough directions provided regarding how to operate everything. I wish all vacation homes were so well marked and organized. Lastly, Katy was so kind and responsive. We only had to reach out to her once and she replied immediately and resolved the very minor issue.
I can say without hesitation that we will return to Madeline Island and will be (hopefully) booking the cottage again.