I'll start my review by saying any vacation is what you make it out to be.
My wife and I, along with another couple, travel frequently and consider ourselves to be laid back and low maintenance. We've always wanted to visit the Chautauqua region in the summer and this year seemed perfect.
Upon arrival, we immediately found the cottage to be cute and nicely decorated. It was the perfect size for (4) people and offered a suitable amount of amenities. It even featured a front yard fire pit and a back patio with a hot tub and plenty of seating. The proximity of its location was close to the lake (directly across the street), and within a few minutes drive to restaurants, grocery stores, etc. Also, the digital handbook received at check-in provided much information about the cottage and surrounding area.
That said, there are negatives and suggestions to be made. First, we thought the interior and exterior needed some love. Wear and tear is normal over time, but a periodic coat of paint can help mask an aging property. Also, the patios were filthy and needed wiped down, de-cobwebbed, and broomed. These are things the "host/service" fees should cover. Visitors wanting to sit on a patio shouldn't have to clean it first. Also, the kitchen has a minor ant issue that needs addressed, but nothing a few traps can't fix.
Lastly, this cottage only has a ceiling fan and two bedroom a/c units. No true ventilation in the bathroom. It can make for an uncomfortable stay if it's hot and humid.