In many ways this property deserves a better rating than I am giving to it. My main reasons for only giving it a "3" are as follows:
1) Primarily, a next to last minute (a day or two ahead of check-in from the property manager noting all the things they do NOT provide or the things they limit. Really? Bring your own tp if our two rolls aren't enough, no coffee filters unless other guests leave them, et al. No personal hygiene products like soap or shampoo? I can't remember the last time some token supplies of these were not provided. None of these are a particular hassle and none of them break the bank for guests OR the property owner to provide. However, it sets a bad tone - in my opinion. No one expects a fully stocked kitchen but, byo coffee filters - really?
In a similar vein, the pots and pans are more than a bit tired, IMO. It would only cost a few dollars to update them and give your guests who want to use the kitchen a better, easier experience.
By the way, , however, thanks for the warning re: well water. It was appreciated.
Second, the front yard is a pie shape in which a big chunck of the view of the lake from the house is blocked by a large shed that the neighbors have. Also, be aware (although this is not the property owner's fault), the neighbors have a bunch of NO TRESPASSING signs up. Ok, we get it "STAY OFF MY LAWN!" However the foregoing force you to use only a tiny sliver/corner of the yard - a good bit away from the house - to sit and relax with a decent, unobstructed view of the lake.
All this being said, it IS on the lake, more or less RIGHT in town and, while it's not likely we will be in that neck of the woods again anytime soon (too bad for us because it is an AWESOME area) and more than lived up to our expectations., we'd rent here again