To start with, the location is a little weird in that it feels like this building is out of place compared to the surrounding buildings. I didn't feel unsafe, just a little quirk. Relatively easy access to NYC, at the mercy of tunnels -- took anywhere from 35-90 minutes to commute into Manhattan.
From the photos I thought the second bedroom was going to be tiny, but it's also got a dresser and wall mounted TV. Everything was in good shape and there were a surprising amount of complementary amenities. Host was quick to respond to any messages I sent.
As other reviews have mentioned, finding the parking is a bit tricky. This is just because the entrance is actually on the cross-street (which is the more major street anyway). It was easy enough to figure out, which is good -- most delivery drivers will need a bit of help finding the entrance as well.
Furniture is functional and aesthetically pleasing, though the actual construction is sometimes a little on the economic side. The beds are thin frames consisting of two rectangles joined together, but you can't tell when you lie on the beds -- they support you just fine. Mattress and pillows (so many pillows) were comfortable. Sound insulation was also really good, I only heard neighbors if they were passing by our front door.
The outside balcony area is large and there's a good bit of outdoor furniture. From the photos I thought it was going to be about 1/3 the size it actually is.
Kitchen cookware is on the inexpensive side (like, almost camping set sometimes), but the cookware is nice and there's a ton of glassware. Different tumblers, mugs, and glasses for alcohol, I was really impressed with the selection!
If I'm in the Newark area I'll definitely try and rent this unit again in the future!