We had a great weekend getaway at Regina's Cottage. The house came exactly as advertised with a nice clean and modern feel while being directly on Lake Cayuga.
I only really had two issues with the house. The first is that the door lock code I was given for check-in did not work. I had to call the rental office for a new code. It was a minor enough issue -- only took about 5-10 minutes to get a new code -- but it's now happened both times I've rented a place managed by Finger Lakes Premier Properties. Not sure what would have happened if I weren't able to check in until later at night.
The second, again minor, issue was with the kitchen. It came fully furnished for use -- oven, stove, pots, pans, etc. -- but was lacking any type of seasoning. Just a simple selection of salt, pepper, basic seasonings, etc., would have gone a long way towards making the kitchen feel more useful.
Outside of that I would recommend the property to others as I feel the issues I had are minor enough and likely would not impact most renters.