Pros:
-amazing access to a wonderful paved bike path which was great for my family (husband + 3 kids, ages 6 - 10)
-on a very quiet road (house is set back from road)
-nice open floor layout on first floor
-comfortable living room seating (couches and chairs)
-great outdoor space (including old tennis court (no nets), with two basketball hoops)
-lots of parking
-nice upstairs (2 bedrooms with 3 beds total)
-cool deck on the back of house, including an outdoor shower on the side of the house with hot water!
Cons:
-22+ minute drive to any town center (VH, OB or Edgartown)
-basement is very musty...so much so we couldn't sleep down there (there's an additional bedroom and bathroom)
-no bathroom on first floor
-hot tub was broken during our stay (which was a prime driver for renting this property in early October). Owners couldn't get it fixed during our stay and only offered $150 reimbursement. When this happened at another property, oddly enough on the Vineyard, we were offered a free night stay OR one night reimbursement - which is what I requested to owner, who refused, which was a bit disappointing.