We've been vacationing in Glenwood Springs for years, and this year our booking came too late to find a reasonably priced house that would accommodate all 7 of us. (1 family of 4 with kids, 1 couple, 1 single) I had never seen historic downtown New Castle before, but it sounded charming, so we booked this property, and couldn't have been happier. It's only 10 minutes from downtown Glenwood, but it's a 1-block walk to an adorable, vibrant historic center in New Castle with some wonderful restaurants and shops.
The house is lovingly restored and spacious. Each bedroom had an air conditioner, which was wonderful because each day was in the mid 90s during our stay. The kitchen was well stocked and functional. (I'm a chef, so a functioning and properly-equipped kitchen is very important to us.)
The large room with 3 beds is up a narrow flight of spiral stairs, and the living room is separated from the kitchen and downstairs bedrooms by a few stairs, so this isn't the right choice for a group with mobility-impaired folks.
The only important thing to note is that this listing shows the house as 2 bathrooms, which is why we booked it. In reality, it is 1 1/2 baths, so there is only 1 shower...not ideal for a group of 7 with teenage girls! The description explained this, but after we had filtered for 2 bathrooms and this listing came up, we booked it without carefully reading about the bathrooms.