The highlight by far is the pool - it totally made our stay. There are jellyfish in the bay as the water heats up, so this was a huge advantage for our group. As a plus, the house has a bunch of fun pool and lawn toys. We had a blast in the pool and on the lawn, which is very spacious.
The house itself comfortably sleeps many people. It was very clean and well-stocked with plenty of towels and linens, dishes and cooking utensils, etc. However, the house was 94 degrees when we arrived, presumably because the AC hadn't been turned on early enough ahead of our arrival. One of the ACs ceased to work on two days of our trip (kept running, but didn't blow cold air). We fiddled with it a bit; eventually turning it off for a while until it did work but the main floor of the house heated up very quickly in the meantime. Only one door (and no windows) has a screen and that screen is broken, so we really relied on that AC. There are ACs in all of the main rooms/sleeping areas, but for a house of that size that is presumably a real draw for summertime use, central air would be a major plus. The open spiral staircase may pose access issues for some travelers and/or could be dangerous for small children.
We had some issues with trash pick-up, communicated with the manager several times and it was finally resolved but we had very full bins all week. I understand that trash pick-up can be challenging on the island...understandably. Overall we would rent this place again.