Tami was an excellent host. We were allowed to check in an hour early and found it extremely easy to do a self-check-in. The house was charming and very clean. The beds were a dream and we slept like babies. We were able to walk all around town, and to three excellent restaurants (Cecil's, Woodrose Cafe, and Humboldt Bar and Grill).
There were a few minor glitches. We found four drinking glasses in the cupboard that were quite dirty. I alerted Tami to the problem and, given the cleanliness of the house, I'm sure she will fix it in the future.
Neither bedroom is super private. One is off the kitchen without completely closed-in walls, and the other has glass French doors off the living room. That said, it worked fine for my husband and me, and the other couple staying with us.
Given the rundown state of Garberville, the property seemed a little overpriced. We rented with a few days' notice and were happy to find something nice and clean at the last minute. But we felt the price might be dropped a bit to be more in line with its surroundings.
All in all, however, we enjoyed our stay.