Ok, some of the perfection was 2 days of sunny 60+ degree weather in mid October.
If you like being within walking distance but in your own building (there is a renter or someone on the other side, but only heard when leaving out the front door), then this place is it.
If you like the view out on the lake, the sunrise view from the big front window and the comfort of the couch, chairs and beds, then this place is it.
If you like the huge fire pit and delicious steaks cooked on it as well as the smoked fish house within view, then this is the place.
My wife and I as well as another couple stayed. I didn't look at the pictures close enough to see that you have to walk through 1 room to get to the other. But the bathroom with doors to the bathroom as well as between the rooms make the inconvenience of that very minimal.
Will stay there again.