On the + side: Place was really big for the 8 of us (4 adults + 4 children). Central A/C was appreciated, and 2 bathrooms as well. We were quite happy with our choice of staying outside NYC and taking the train from Journal square - about 10-15 min walk. Neighborhood was ok during the day, but I wouldn't have wandered alone at night (it might be ok, but we didn't know the neighborhood). We could park one car in the designated spot, and had no problem parking the other one in the street (but be vigilant of notices because you have to switch sides from one day to another).
On the - side: cleanliness is irregular: both showers had very obvious mold in them, items from previous tenants were found under the beds. Clearly an ant problem in the kitchen (very small ants). More table cutlery would be needed, and more pots & pans as well.
Located on 3rd floor - to be taken into consideration if you don't want to carry your luggage for 2 flights of stairs (but they're quite large).
Overall, we enjoyed our stay!