Our extended family of 12 stayed at Rotunda for 5 nights in January. The property is amazing…. Very true to photos and description. Lots of outdoor, dining, and indoor living space for everyone, with breathtaking views at every turn. The kitchen was recently renovated ( huge), which explains the lack of kitchen staples ( condiments etc). House manager David met us promptly in Cruz Bay and took us through the house room by room. He was very helpful and responsive .
As far as accessibility to private Peter Bay beach, we were warned and disappointed. Rough road and trail down, with no parking available on our first day. Other North Shore beaches are close and beautiful. The villa pool is great, but a little cool during our stay. Pool toys, snorkel equipment… everything you could need.
We Highly recommend Rotunda… you’ll never forget your stay.